3 steps for when you're asked a question you didn't prepare for


Hey Reader,

If you spend hours preparing for every presentation, every meeting, and you still blank the moment someone asks something you didn't rehearse a script for - read this one twice.

Today is all about The dreaded Q&A Section

At this point you could recite that report you're due to present on in your sleep, upside down, possibly backwards. Admittedly, that's not actually the skill you need.

You're standing there presenting exactly what you rehearsed, when someone leans in and asks something you didn't see coming. Rude.

You're caught off-guard. Suddenly, you can't catch your breath. Your palms go clammy. Words you never planned to say start tumbling out, half-finished thoughts competing for airtime, burying the one point you actually wanted to make under a panic-driven ramble.

You're petrified you don't look anywhere near as knowledgeable as you actually are.

Somehow you get through it. They thank you, you sit down, equal parts relieved it's over, and also furious with yourself, because now your brain hands you the perfect answer, three minutes too late. Impeccable timing, as always.

You tell yourself you didn't prepare well enough. That if you'd just thought of that question, you'd have delivered it with ease.

You're wrong.

You knew the answer. You had it - you could feel it sitting right there when they asked. What happened wasn't a glaring gap in knowledge.

It was a physical reaction, over in a split second. The moment you realised it was a question you hadn't prepared for, something small and imperceptible fired in your body - a sharp intake of breath, maybe held without you noticing.

But your body noticed.

And before your knowledge could reach your mouth, it went to war for you - triggering a response built to get you away from threat. Part of that response is shutting off access to language and flexible thought - to the part of your brain that stores the answer, because it doesn't think that part of your brain is necessary when it's trying to get you out of what it thinks is a threatening situation.

Your body read the moment as danger and tried to get you out of there.

But...you can't exactly run out of the meeting room screaming, tempting as it is. Experience tells me that ruins your street cred, alongside any chance of promotion.

So what actually helps?

First: Stop telling yourself you don't know enough.

You do. Probably more than everyone else in that room combined. You DEFINITELY know more than Chad - all he's ever done since he arrived is smirk.

The blank was never down to lack of information. Consider this - if you'd had 5 minutes to sit down and think out an answer - you'd have been able to do it. You know enough!

Second: Extend your exhale.

I know, I know. I say "extend your exhale" so often at this point it's probably going to end up as my epitaph. "She extended her last exhale."

BUT...

Exhaling slowly through your nose, longer than your inhale, is one of the fastest ways to signal to your nervous system that you're not actually under threat. It engages your vagus nerve and starts pulling you out of that fight or flight state in real time. A few seconds of that before you speak buys your brain back the access it just lost.

Third, and this is longer term - retrain your body's response to the room itself, not just managing it in the moment.

When your nervous system stops running hypervigilant standby before you've even opened your mouth, the unpredictability of a Q&A stops being the threat it currently is. That's when you get to actually show people the depth of what you know, instead of performing damage control on a blank. It takes time, repetition, and support to actually change what your nervous system does the second the pressure's on.

When you do all that? You'd be surprised at how easily your answers come to you and how impressed they all start looking with your depth of knowledge.

There are a few different ways people react under pressure like this.

I've grouped them into three observable patterns. One way to stop fumbling your way through the Q&A section is understanding which category you fall into.

​Take the quiz to find yours ​

Steady together,

Ellie

P.S. Next week I'm dropping in with a quick update on the kind of support that third point actually requires. Keep an eye out for that.

Ellie Smith | Public Speaking Coach

For professionals who lose their train of thought, ramble, or feel their body take over when the pressure is on. Every week, you'll receive practical strategies using a body-first approach to help you stay steady and communicate clearly and coherently so your expertise is finally recognized and respected.

Read more from Ellie Smith | Public Speaking Coach

Hey Reader, I recently read a newsletter that listed 25 jobs you could hand over to AI, each with the exact instructions to copy. What I loved about it was that every job was designed to help you use AI more efficiently, and therefore a lot less. That’s always been my goal. If I’m going to use AI, I want to make the most of my time there, not waste the planet’s resources through careless use of it. It got me thinking about how to apply the same principle to something completely different: my...

Hey Reader, Let me introduce you to Phoebe. Phoebe is really good at her job. She works in publishing. She’s excited to go to work every day (and, let’s be honest, just as excited to finish), and she loves the challenge it gives her. It also means a lot of pitches and presentations. She’s been given the chance to lead a pitch to a prospective client who could bring in serious revenue for the company. She’s worked hard on it. Her slides are down to a T, with trigger words placed exactly where...

Hey Reader, Quick behind-the-scenes note. I'm mid-build on something, and I'd rather bring you in on what's going on than wait until it's polished before sharing it with you. You may have heard me talk about the Steady Speaker Power Hour in previous emails. Until now, it's been a general hour of support for dealing with speaking nerves. I'm now rebuilding it around one specific issue: the moment your mind goes blank mid-presentation. One hour can't fix every issue we face when giving a...